The Milwaukee Journal-Sentinel suggests that the slow pace of job creation in Wisconsin, not recall campaign shenanigans, may be Scott Walker’s real enemy in his upcoming re-election campaign:
In each of Walker’s first three years, Wisconsin has added private-sector jobs more slowly than the nation as whole, and the gap is sizable. Wisconsin has averaged 1.3% in annual private-sector job growth since 2010; the national average has been 2.1%. Wisconsin’s ranking in private-sector job growth was 35 among the 50 states in 2011, 36 in 2012 and 37 in 2013.
Combining the first three years of Walker’s term, the state ranks behind all its closest and most comparable Midwest neighbors: Michigan (6 of 50), Indiana (15), Minnesota (20), Ohio (25), Iowa (28) and Illinois (33).
I think this is slightly unfair to Walker! Part of the reason Michigan is doing so well in job growth since 2010 is that Michigan was hammered so very, very hard by the recession. It had more room to grow. Indiana’s unemployment rate was roughly similar to Wisconsin’s in the years leading up to the crash, but shot up to 10.8% as the economy bottomed out (WI never went over 9.2%.) Now Indiana and Wisconsin are about even again.
But I do mean slightly unfair. After all, Walker ran on a change platform, arguing that Jim Doyle’s administration had tanked the state’s economy. In fact, Wisconsin weathered the recession much better than a lot of our neighbor states did. (The last years Wisconsin was above the median for private-sector job growth? 2008 and 2010, both under Doyle.) There’s some karmic fairness at play, should that fact come back to make Walker look like a weak job creator compared to his fellow governors.