i, you sneaky bastard

Childhood memory:  I learned that i is formally defined to be the square root of -1.  Well, I thought, that worked well, what about the square root of i?  Surely that must be yet a new kind of number.  I just had to check that (a+bi)^2 can never be i.  But whoa, you can solve that!  (sqrt(2)/2) + (sqrt(2)/2)i does the trick.  I was kind of bowled over by this.  i, you sneaky bastard — you anticipated my next move and got ahead of me!  I had no idea what “algebraically closed” meant, or anything like that.  But it was one of my first experience of the incredible power of the right definition.  Once the definition is right, you can just do everything.


6 thoughts on “i, you sneaky bastard

  1. My memory of figuring out mathematics as a teenager is being really bored at my grandparents’ place, realizing that one could use telescoping series to figure out the sum of the first n k-th powers, and doing some long hand calculations of the actual polynomials. At some point I got a Lotus spreadsheet to calculate what I now know are appropriate transforms of the first 20 or so Bernoulli numbers.

    I wonder if someone can take these memories and predict that I turned out (roughly speaking) an algebraic combinatorialist and you turned out (roughly speaking) an arithmetic geometer.

  2. Callan says:

    Interestingly Deligne seems to have had precisely the same thought as documented in this interview: https://www.simonsfoundation.org/science_lives_video/pierre-deligne/

  3. sniffnoy says:

    I suspect this may be a common thing, I remember doing this back in middle school as well.

  4. Kevin says:

    I just hit the sqrt button on my TI-83 and got .70710678 + .70710678i. Figured that decimal had some meaning, so on a hunch I squared it and got .4999999. Only then did I formally verify that sqrt(1/2) + sqrt(1/2)i works.

  5. Jeremy Roach says:

    @Kevin I believe the four color theorem was proved similarly, with a calculator proof assistant.

  6. valuevar says:

    Hey! That’s *my* childhood memory!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: